Choosing the appropriate speakers may make a huge impact on automotive audio systems. Which of the two common options—component vs coaxial speakers is best for you? To assist you in making an informed choice, we’ll compare the two categories of speakers in this post.
General Overview: Introducing The Component Speakers And Coaxial Speakers
Before we dive into the comparison, let’s take a closer look at coaxial and component.
Component speakers, also known as separates, consist of multiple speaker units. Each unit is designed to produce a specific range of frequencies. A typical component speaker system includes woofers, tweeters, and crossovers.
The woofer produces low-frequency sounds, while the tweeter produces high-frequency sounds. The crossover separates the audio signal into different frequency ranges and sends them to the appropriate speaker unit. This results in clearer and more accurate sound reproduction.
Coaxial speakers, also known as full-range speakers, combine multiple speaker units into one. The woofer and tweeter are mounted together, with the tweeter positioned in the center of the woofer.
This design allows for a more compact speaker that can produce a full range of frequencies. These products are easier to install and generally more affordable than component types. However, they may not offer the same level of sound quality and customization as component ones.
Read more: Parallel Vs Series Speakers
Table Of Comparison: Key Specifications
|Key specification||Component speaker||Coaxial speaker|
|Dimensions||3.5 inches – 4×10 inches||3.5 inches – 4×10 inches|
|Weight||Vary depending on the models||Vary depending on the models|
|Type||Typically 2-way or more||2-way|
|Frequency response||60Hz – 20.000Hz||80Hz – 20.000Hz|
|Sensitivity||87dB – 90dB||87dB – 93dB|
|Impedance||4 ohms, 6 ohms, 8 ohms||4 ohms, 6 ohms, 8 ohms|
|Power range||65W – 100W||35W – 65W|
Comparing Component Speakers And Coaxial Speakers
Let’s examine the differences between coaxial and component speaker types in more detail, including installation costs, sound quality, customizability, and room needs.
Cost and installation
Component speakers are generally more expensive than coaxial types due to their more complex design and higher sound quality.
They also require more time and expertise to install, as each speaker unit needs to be mounted separately and the crossover needs to be properly configured. This can add to the overall cost of the system.
Coaxial types, on the other hand, are more affordable and easier to install, as they combine multiple speaker units into one. This makes them a popular choice for those looking for a simple and cost-effective upgrade to their car’s audio system.
Component speakers offer superior sound quality compared to coaxial choices. The separate speaker units allow for more accurate sound reproduction and a wider frequency range.
Coaxial speakers, while still capable of producing good sound quality, may not offer the same level of clarity and accuracy as the other one.
Customization and space requirements
Component products offer more customization options than coaxial types. You can choose the size and type of each speaker unit to suit your specific needs.
However, this also means that component choices require more space for installation. Coaxial products are more compact and require less space for installation.
Which Is Better, The Component Or The Coaxial Speaker?
Your own demands and tastes will determine how to respond to this question. Despite being more expensive and requiring more installation skills, component speakers have better sound quality and customization options.
Coaxial speakers are less expensive and simpler to install. However, they might not provide the same level of quality as the other one. In the end, your budget, your goals for your car audio system, and your personal preferences will determine which option is ideal for you.
Read more: 6 Ohm Vs 8 Ohm Speakers
Both coaxial and component speakers have benefits and drawbacks. When deciding between the two, it’s crucial to take your own requirements and tastes into account. There is a speaker option that will suit your demands, regardless of whether sound quality, price, or ease of installation are your top priorities.
- Can I use both component and coaxial speakers together?
Yes, you can use both these two types together in a car audio system. However, it's important to properly configure the system to ensure the best sound quality.
- Do I need an amplifier for components or coaxial speakers?
Depending on how much power your speaker can handle as well as the power output of your head unit or receiver, you may or may not need an amplifier. Better sound quality and volume can be achieved by using an amplifier, which can supply the products with additional power.
- How do I choose between component and coaxial speakers?
Take into account your budget, the objectives of your automobile audio system, and your personal preferences when deciding between these two options.